Blog
Living the story I’m in – December reflections
-1-
December reflections – my secular advent
Early December is a favourite time for me. There is a mood of stillness in the quiet December skies. Each day I walk out with the dog or jog slowly around Great Chalfield Manor in Wiltshire near where I live. Though there is Christmas busyness in nearby Bath, life feels as though it is starting to suspend itself. This time of year is also tinged with memories of loss: my father died on the 4th of December many years ago and my mother became severely ill this time last year. So it is a time of remembering: sitting in darkened, hushed rooms. Moving through tinsel clad hospital corridors untouched by the glitter. Maybe this is why Patrick Kavanagh’s poem about Advent from my schooldays has come to mean more and more to me each year, even though it’s drenched in catholic imagery:
We’ve tested and tasted too much lover,
Through a chink too wide there comes in no wonder.
But here in the advent darkened room,the dry black bread and sugarless tea of penance will charm back the luxury of a child’s soul
Though I’ve long said goodbye to my childhood Catholicism with its penance and guilt, a secular Advent does live on in me. Kavanagh’s poem evokes a mood of mystery that I don’t give up so easily. It speaks to a sense of quietness, in the landscape, in me around this time of the year.
Space to ask, “What’s this year been about?”, and to return to the luxury of a child’s soul asking, “what do I see now?”
-2-
Brexit – the radio chirps, and the tide goes out
I see that Brexit is not bothering me in the same way as it did. The radio burst into life this morning with more excited news. “Coming up we’ll have Theresa May on the programme”, the Radio4 presenter announced chirpily. Today is the 6th December, and the economic implications of her Brexit plan will be debated later today in parliament. This morning, as always, I switched the radio off, but noticed I didn’t thump my hand down on the off switch with the same force I’d gotten into the habit of doing. For a year I couldn’t listen to it. But there’s so much chaos now that it’s become interesting again. Article 50 could be revoked. The government might fall. In the FT an article by David McWilliams tells us that, politics aside, demographics and economics suggest Northern Ireland could be better off allying to the Republic. Unthinkable? The move from rhetoric to enactment creates a different mood as it starts to paint in the practical reality. There is a frisson of unpredictability to all this even if it’s not palatable. Anything could happen.
Brexit tidings come to me
I’ve received a letter from work reassuring me that after the 29th of March, I’ll be fine. I’ll have two years to apply for a work-permit – no problem at all. And this is true. But with this letter a distinction is made visible that wasn’t even worth mentioning before -I’m an Irish person living in the UK. It’s no longer just about the accent.
Meanwhile a friend tells me the channel tunnel has written to say that dogs may no longer be allowed across to France. “Oh why did the remain campaign not talk about that!?” we lament. Each time I’ve travelled back and forth to Ireland this year, which is a lot, I’ve wondered how the queues in and out of the country will be affected after Brexit. I imagine the kind of rage it might create as day after day, as the borders build up with tailbacks reminiscent of Eastern Europe in the late 80s.
I was doing my shopping yesterday in Sainsburys and noticed that the sausages have now been rebranded. Gone are the Toulouse and Sicilian flavours. Replaced by blander UK-centric labelling like ‘herby’, ‘meaty’, ‘Lincolnshire’ and so on. “Is this like the tide going out far before a tsunami hits?” I wonder. I think of writing to Sainsburys to remind them that 48% of the country voted to remain, but by the time I get home, my irate energy has evaporated.
The noise of Brexit is a bit like the shoppers in Bath – it’s distant but I know it’s happening. I’ve stopped stopping my ears. It’s somehow become bearable.
Don’t get me wrong. I still hate Brexit and wish it never happened. I still want David Cameron sitting in his garden shed feeling sorry – deeply sorry for what he unleashed. But it is happening, and I’ve finally stopped denying it. And with that, it seems, anything can happen.
-3-
Greta tells us to grow up.
Meanwhile something else is also happening. Tidings of the seriousness of climate change have long been coming through. In October further dire warnings have being issued in response to the latest report from expert scientific panels. Yet related headlines such as: final call to save the world from ‘Climate Catastrophe’ likely lands for many people like background noise. Indeed philosopher and commentator on climate denial, John Foster has long suggested that this kind of future-focussed ‘wake-up call’ language actually anaesthetizes our abilities to be practical in the present. But no matter, because the future is stealthily arriving anyway. Greta Thunberg, a 15-year old Swedish girl said as much this week at the climate talks in Katowice, Poland when she addressed the UN Secretary general saying:
We have come here to let [you] know that change is coming whether they like it or not. The people will rise to the challenge. And since our leaders are behaving like children, we will have to take the responsibility they should have taken long ago.
Greta Thunberg (Greta Thunberg’s speech to the UN secretary general)
The charge of childishness may seem naïve. More charitably I might see our leaders as trapped inside a political pattern. But Greta brought freshness to old tidings. In its simplicity, her message is potent – change is coming anyway. As someone who’s followed the science for a while now I know a little about the possible trajectories; and behind the headlines, the October IPCC report is very bad news indeed. To put it very simply – anything over 1.5 degrees temperature increase is bad, over 2 degrees is potentially terrible and 5 or 6 degrees is unthinkable. Yet it is now becoming thinkable. There is a very real possibility that by the end of the century the unthinkable may be where we will have headed.
I do not like this. I started working on research relating to climate mitigation in 2005. At that time 2020 was a golden date by which so much carbon reduction needed to have happened in the UK and further afield. It was a year blessedly far out in the future. As it turns out 2020 is now the year after next. And as it turns out 2018 saw the highest global emissions. The facts speak for themselves.
There are some connections here to Brexit and my own denial. Might there a be similarity in the patterns of tardy realization and willful avoidance? Is it inherent in our political systems to address the implications of something only as it is occurring? Is it inherent in me and human nature to look angrily away from something I can’t bear the thought of? To throw my hand onto the off switch?
-4-
Civilisation just can’t be finishing….can it?
In a recent chilling talk with the provocative title: “Civilisation is finished, so what is to be done?” the philosopher and long-time green campaigner Rupert Read exhorts us not to look away from the dire scenario I’ve outlined above. Rupert thinks a civilisation-threatening hike in global temperature is fairly likely and, to be honest, I do too. Let’s neutrally call this a possible scenario – scenario VW (for scenario very warm). This gets us away from the more emotive descriptions like this being a ‘worst-case’ or ‘doom-and-gloom’ scenario. Even that language conveys a dual judgment that such a thing is firstly unlikely to happen and secondly, that anyone who does consider this scenario is themselves tainted as a doomsayer or a pessimistic killjoy.
Nobody wants Scenario VW but thinking about it isn’t a crime – it may be a responsibility. Rupert’s argument is that, despite what we hope for, we have to entertain scenario VW because if we spend all our time working on getting to Scenario OK and then don’t arrive there we have wasted so much valuable time. This is another version of the precautionary principle. “Think ahead guys”, he’s saying. “Entertain the possibility,” for goodness sake, “protect civilization just in case”. The thing is, as Greta said, it’s happening anyway.
As I watched Rupert’s talk, feeling uneasy with it, I realised that there was a structure of thinking that he was inviting us into – to get better at holding multiple stories in our mind. And I mean holding the possibility of them emotionally rather than rationally. Not so that we can equivocate between them by weighing up the pros and cons, but rather so that the stories of our time can live properly in us, and in me. This begs the question of ‘how am I living the story of this time?’ – and that ‘feels’ like a different question to what I have been asking myself which is: “what story can I be part of creating?”
-5-
The mystery and possibility of living in multiple stories
Thomas Berry’s quote has always been an inspiration to me:
It’s all a question of story. We are in trouble just now because we do not have a good story. We are in between stories. The old story, the account of how we fit into the world, is no longer effective. Yet we have not learned the new story
Thomas Berry
I always interpreted Berry’s new story as something I could play a part in creating: a positive story of a sustainable future that would ‘drown-out’ other possibilities. But my point of view is shifting. Some sort of new story is happening and expressing itself no matter what. If I can be fully living in that, I might better be able to see the possible stories that are opening out from it. Main thing is to have at least two of them in mind! With this everything is more tentative: more desperate and more possible. Loosening a grip on one desired story and living in multiple ones is the opposite of giving up. Recognizing this brings immense mystery and possibility – as Patrick Kavanagh said there was a ‘newness in every stale thing when we looked at it as children” and a “spirit shocking wonder” in seeing each moment afresh: after all, anything can happen.
Thank you for reading! Click on the subscribe button here to hear about future postings
